If your third-party risk management (TPRM) program is focused solely on cybersecurity, then you’re only getting a partial view of risk – what’s commonly visible above the water line. But so much more risk exists below the surface. For example, do you know whether your vendors are meeting SLA requirements? Can you assess the strength of their ethics and anti-bribery and corruption (ABAC) policies? How socially and environmentally conscious are your supplier chain partners?
Prevalent recently surveyed senior decision makers about their organizations’ TPRM focus areas, stakeholders and challenges. Our goal was to understand the current, real-world state of third-party risk management programs. What we found is that many companies struggle to identify the reputation-wrecking business risks that lurk beneath the cybersecurity surface.
In the Prevalent 2021 Third-Party Risk Management Study, we present the full results of the survey and chart strategies for navigating the icy waters of vendor and supplier risk today. This post shares key findings from the study and outlines guidance for expanding your risk visibility throughout the third-party lifecycle.
Results of this year’s study point to four primary observations:
Two of the biggest events of 2020 – the COVID-19 pandemic and the social and racial justice movements – had little to do with cybersecurity but triggered important third-party risk activities. In fact, 83% of study respondents reported that the pandemic spurred an increased focus on third-party risk at their organizations. However, while the pandemic brought unprecedented challenges for supply chain risk management and vendor performance management, fewer than half of respondents were actively tracking supply chain and performance risks.
At the same time, the ongoing justice movements underscore the importance of working with partners who have sound diversity and ESG policies. Despite this, the study found that few companies actively track third-party risks related to labor standards, the environment and human rights.
Every third-party business relationship follows a lifecycle along these lines: pre-contract due diligence, contracting, onboarding, risk assessment, performance management, and offboarding. Interestingly, the number-one challenge cited by study respondents was a lack of pre-contract due diligence. More surprisingly, 59% of companies say they do not actively assess third-party risks during offboarding, which can open the door to data exposures and compliance violations. Need further proof? Just ask Morgan Stanley.
Third-party risk management has long been the domain of IT and security teams. Our study affirms this, with 50% of respondents reporting that IT and security own TPRM in their organizations. And 55% of organizations saw increased ownership by security over the past year. The problem is, only 22% saw an increase in ownership by procurement teams. This trend is concerning, as risks increasingly fall outside of the typical cybersecurity area of responsibility.
70% of respondents indicated that outsourcing is the preferred method of managing third-party risk. Why? Because a shockingly large number of practitioners (42%) still use spreadsheets as the primary mechanism for vendor risk assessments – and 65% aren’t satisfied with this approach. Respondents also cited the need for a broader range of third-party risk intelligence sources a key to achieving TPRM success.
Click the preview to download a PDF of the complete infographic.
Here are four (4) recommendations to chart a better course through third-party risks:
Vendor risk management isn’t just a security and compliance problem. Many types of risks can impact an organization’s ability to produce, manage, and distribute goods and services. Therefore, security and business teams must work together to expand the scope of vendor risk assessments to include two areas in addition to cybersecurity:
Look for solutions that normalize monitoring data and correlate it against risk assessment findings to escalate potential risks and identify recommended remediations. Incorporating a broad range of risk intelligence sources will help security and procurement teams make better-informed decisions.
Disjointed approaches to assessing third-party risk leave gaps – and gaps introduce risk. You can unify IT security and business teams with a TPRM platform solution that provides a central source for everything from vendor profiles and contracts, to assessment results and compliance reports, to performance metrics and remediation logs. Having a single solution ensures that the entire organization is using the same data to make risk-based decisions.
Security, compliance and operational issues can crop up at any time during a vendor or supplier relationship, so it’s important to address risk at each stage of the third-party lifecycle. Be sure to download the full report for guidance on what look for at each step of the vendor risk lifecycle, including:
The results of this study show that the preferred method of TPRM includes outsourcing on some level. Third-party risk management experts can manage the vendor lifecycle on your behalf – from onboarding vendors and collecting evidence, to reviewing assessments for completeness, identifying risks, and providing remediation guidance. As a result, you can safely navigate dangerous waters by efficiently scaling your TPRM program, reducing vendor risk, and simplifying compliance without burdening your internal staff.
The 2021 Third-Party Risk Management Study
This definitive report from Prevalent is loaded with insightful data, analysis and recommendations from our survey of global risk management practitioners.
We found that most companies are missing key risks at more than one stage of the vendor risk lifecycle, leaving their companies exposed to unseen risks. How is your third-party risk management program navigating these challenges compared to the respondents to our survey? Download the full results and review the infographic to benchmark your own TPRM practices.
For more on how Prevalent can help address third-party risk management challenges, request a demo of our platform today.
Read an analysis of vendor risk management market trends and key solution evaluation criteria.
11/18/2024
Read the findings from our annual TPRM study and implement these best practices to put out...
05/08/2024
Prevalent believes it is differentiated by delivering comprehensive coverage of multiple risk types and by delivering...
12/12/2023